| Author |
File Description |
| Feonor |
Posted on 10/16/06 @ 11:29 AM (updated 10/19/06)
| File Details |
|---|
| Number of Scenarios: |
21 |
| Difficulty: |
Mod-Hard |
This is a 21 scenerio campaign based on the books by tolkein and on the films by Peter Jackson. All scenerios are possible to win without cheats, some are just REALLY HARD.
please leave feedback.
This includes all three parts of LOTR.
-Feonor |
| Author | Comments & Reviews ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only ) |
|---|
WillNotAllow
(id: GeorgeROR) |
Posted on 10/18/06 @ 05:26 PM
That being said I went through most of them, basically being interesting warrior/scout scenes. Keep up the good effort. |
Feonor
File Author |
Posted on 10/19/06 @ 03:17 PM |
WillNotAllow
(id: GeorgeROR) |
Posted on 10/21/06 @ 11:24 AM
DID YOU CHECK TO SEE IF THERE WAS ANOTHER LOTR CPX OUT THAR? well not that it matters...[Edited on 11/01/06 @ 08:40 PM]
|
| Servant_of_Odin |
Posted on 11/21/06 @ 09:10 PM
Horrible. Pretty much all but one scenario were impossible to beat. Needs to be fixed
Balance: 2.5
You expect me to get through a load of towers with two slingers?!?!?!?!?
Creativity: 3
Was pretty much the same as LOTR, but I couldn't give this a 2.
Map Design: 1.9
Every map was about 50% bare space that you could've filled with something.
Story/Instructions: 3.5
These were pretty clear, so no horrible rating.
Additional Comments:
This really needs fixing. I am deleting the scenarios until this happens. (There were a lot of spelling errors, too. Rohirrim has no "u".) |
WillNotAllow
(id: GeorgeROR) |
Posted on 11/22/06 @ 11:56 AM [Edited on 11/22/06 @ 12:53 PM]
|
| Nezon |
Posted on 11/23/06 @ 05:54 AM
Here is my review:
Playability: 3 - Well, not so good here because, some of the scenarios are really hard to beat. Though they are very acurate to the storyline. It was fun at times such as helms deep and The "Something" Fields, But there was too much walking, but thats the way lotr is...
:(
Balance: 2 - At times it was easy, at times it was hard, at times it was impossible, so I used "homerun"
Creativity: 2.5 - Well I can see that you concentrate on the one place, and the other half of the map is left blank, I think you should place rivers or whatever on there makes it look less dull ;)
Map design: It was really close to the actual story, but some parts I got lost in. Im not the walking type =]
Story/Instructions: 3 - I liked how you put dialoge in, but it was lacking clear instructions.
OVERALL: I would say, this game was pretty chalenging, Helms Deep was the one that inspired me to make "The Fall of the Republic"
FEEDBACK: Remember to make the game a little more easier, and fill up those blank spots.
Hope you dont get offended, Good luck on your other maps ;)
www.freewebs.com/corruption_inc
Nezon |
| Lolbroek |
Posted on 12/08/06 @ 09:35 AM |
| AOE_mapper_newb |
Posted on 12/12/06 @ 06:39 AM
Not bad but one scenario where there were merry and that other hobbit (forgot name)was held prisoner in the orc camp I keep getting crushed, this happened 5 times is a row.
Balance: 1.8
the one where there was a orc camp and riders of rohan, the riders didn't attack quick enuf and it took me a long time to do it, the one with the battle at mordors gates the enemy's army mostly consited of clubs and normal bowmans, pretty unfair for the comp player i say.
Creativity: 3.5
The story was really accurate to the books, so this is one of the good things about it.
Map Design: 1.3
Sorry the thing is there are blank spaces everywhere in this campaign, try putting swamps, forest made out of gaia trees and decorate the cities, they look pretty bare.
when u recycled the first map and then turned it into scoring of the shire, it was pretty wierd mainley because u didn't delete player 4! (which is arigon in the first one)
Story/Instructions: 3.5
instructions are very clear.
Additional Comments:
Get the enchanced editor it is really good. |
Feonor
File Author |
Posted on 12/12/06 @ 03:43 PM |
| chr1s |
Posted on 12/15/06 @ 01:46 AM
[Edited on 12/15/06 @ 12:38 PM]
|
