Newt (and Heir) are being nit picky, is all. Mostly random, but they seem the scummiest to me so far.

Read.
Oh, I will TRY.


Mozzy, Heir is like that, trust me.

Mozzy, Heir is like that, trust me.

Totally. All my Facebook friends know this. You should have one.

Also, I'm being this way because we have nothing to go on and doing stuff like this might provoke/reveal something.

It's not like I take joy in being pedantic (yes, Gil, I know this a total lie).

Nice pic Heir.

Yay! Thanks CV!

It took me a bit to realize it was you though

Mozzy, let me get this straight. You are voting for me (and finding Heir suspicious) because we think it's unusual that someone says 'I don't know if I'm a miller or not.' Why would you assume that you might be if you're not explicitly told that you are? Of course it's possible, but you have to assume that you aren't. Otherwise it looks odd and wastes precious time from cops who might otherwise investigate the claim. Of course, we've lost our cop, so that seems unlikely to happen, unless we have another one. The point is, however, that I don't think it is unreasonable to question the reasons behind that statement.

He said simply that, as far as he knows, he is not a miller. He used a throwaway phrase, is all. Nothing suspicious about that, and to pounce on him that way sets a tiny alarm off for me.

Your vote seems mostly random, and mine is also mostly random. Your reasons, though, seem... je ne sais quoi.

He said simply that, as far as he knows, he is not a miller.

He didn't say as far as he knows. He said almost surely. That suggests ambiguity, and that is what both me and Newt were raising questions against.

Semantics, Heir.

Is that a rebuke? I did apologize.

'Almost surely' and 'as far as I know' amount to the same thing.

Still fighting about my choice of words ?

I apologize that what I said was redundant, but I have the habit of saying all the redundant things as well what I should say Must be because I read too much English fantasy literature, which makes my speaking style somewhat archaic at times

About the new description CV made of the night-kill, I think that the killer was lord Sidius or count Dooku (didn't he use lightning against Yoda when they fought?), considering the "lightning" (or whatever the term is CV used ) used to incinerate THY. I suppose whichever it was is the Godfather (if there IS one, that is).

Nothing in that would help us find the culprit, though

Where are the other people besides us active ramblers (me, Heir and Mozzarella among a few others)? There are some who haven't posted unless I miss my guess. CV, you gotta keep a tight rein on everybody.

Have you accepted my invite (I accepted yours) or do you just use MSN so rarely I didn't even see you during the weekend, even though I didn't even sleep between saturday and sunday incase you might show up (among other reasons )

Oh, and since there's no editing allowed, I'll already apologize fo whatever spelling mistakes I'll do, since I most likely don't want to read through my blatherings to find any errors I've made

Someone Really has to tell me how this whole thing works please. It's my first time.

We talk a lot, searching for inconsistencies and other suspicious stuff, lynch someone (hopefully) guilty or do a no lynch, wait over the night, analyze what happens, rinse and repeat until we win. Simple enough I suggest you read some old Mafia (like the holy grail mafia, which I read before my first mafia at AoK (Canada Mafia, which I won due to sheer luck ))

'Almost surely' and 'as far as I know' amount to the same thing.

They don't. 'Almost surely' implies that your role has ambiguity, 'as far as I know' doesn't leave any room for that at all.

@AoM - What Major said.

But stop arguing with me over this and try to find a way to kick-start the game. I have absolutely no ideas except for a random claim.

First time Heir doesn't have a clue what to do!

This game's gonna be good!

@AoM- Do that. Read a lot of previous mafia games. [ You would see a list of awards nomination over at HG main. Pick up games from there.]

I also started just couple of months back, so I understand your utter confusion.
Oh, and please be active. As newbies, we need to be.

Even a random claim is of limited use if we don't get more people posting than we already have. At the moment, there's only about five of us active.

I can understand how the game might seem confusing at first but it really is quite straightforward once you get into it.

First time Heir doesn't have a clue what to do!

I do, I did indeed mention a random claim, I'm just not sure whether that's the best way forward.

You know what we need now? Activity.

We need to know if the other players got any flavor or something like that.

I have no problems with doing a random claim, if no-one else has any information to present to us.

*Looks worriedly at the rapidly incoming saturday deadline*

Guys? GUYS? We gotta do something or the baddies are gonna get a free night-kill. I'm leaning more and more strongly towards mass-claim, unless someone actually comes up with something productive, as this time we don't have a person like CV muddling things up

Also, where are all the inactive people, POST people POST

Vote: Henrz

Because he's been posting elsewhere but not here, but mostly it's random.

I'll trust Heir's judgement I don't follow other players' activities, so I can't comment on the activityness any more than say that he hasn't posted very much regarding this mafia <.< Although I seem to recall someone saying he's not very active on mafias anyways. That's no excuse though.

Besides, any lead is better than none, and failure to post here when posting elsewhere is indeed a grave offense, regardless of whether it means scummy behavior or just the fact he has forgotten all about this game or just that he doesn't care enough to post, which indicates disrespect towards everyone else in this game.

VOTE: Henrz

I could be scum.