I have explained that his plan is not the best regardless of wether or not you think I am town you should still be able to think for yourself. My plan makes more sense and I don't see how people can be not even appear to consider it, how can you be against lynching the person cop has a guilty investigation on?

So unless you can say what your plan of action is tomorrow when cop hasn't investigated someone you should defiantly not be trying to finish the lynch today.

Blatant's accusation could explain why Herr would reveal cult early on. By saying that he isn't converted when in fact he is, and by saying that only certain characters could be converted when it is probable that any character could, he would be leading town into thinking mass claim is bad for town, as we have done day 2. And a mass claim would certainly hurt a cult that could convert anyone.

It seems I owe you an apology for doubting you, Ash, although I still find it slightly fishy that Blatant would coincidentally have investigated both you and Herr and announced it only after I started pressuring.

I don't want to vote yet because if Blatant is lying and we lynch scragins, then it would pretty much be game over right there.

I don't want to vote yet because if Blatant is lying and we lynch scragins, then it would pretty much be game over right there.

Actually Blatant doesn't need to be lying he never investigated me.

And a mass claim would certainly hurt a cult that could convert anyone.

Why would a mass claim hurt a cult that could convert anyone? At best I see it being inconsequential to the aims of any cult.

Well it seems like I am some uninformed miller or something and I have been doomed through no fault of mine, I will definitely be having words with Yeeb if that ends up being the case. As of now, I will follow the town's wishes and Vote: Scragins

Well it seems like I am some uninformed miller or something

That something being scum.

Also don't ask questions and then end the day that is just silly. Just as silly to follow the towns wishes to have you killed in the night.

A lead? Could it be true?
The town took the opportunity, scragins simply wasn't fitting in.

Mike Ehrmantraut played by scragins has been lynched. DEA investigation revealed that Mike was a key player in the meth business. He had the ability to conceal evidence or protect a cult member.


It is now Night 3
Day begins in ~48 hours

Screams. One bullet.

Jesse Pinkman played by Herr has been killed... BITCH! Jesse was involved with meth production.



It is now day 4. 6 alive, so 4 to lynch.

[This message has been edited by Yeebaagooon (edited 06-21-2014 @ 04:02 AM).]

Okay, so I killed Herr last night as promised. Apparently I then found a knife on my desk and a note warning me not to push the investigation too far, because I may not like the results. Does anyone else have any news?

I'd also like to add that we need to be very careful with so few people left, as we aren't sure just how many cult members remain.

If we are going off of behavior, I'm suspicious of Zeno, who was supportive of both Herr and scragins and who came after me as soon as I went after them. He did claim Marie Schrader, which solid second to Hank, but if every player in the game is convertible, then that does not mean anything. Since Herr turned out to be lying, it is possible that the cult can convert anybody, including Zeno.

Since Herr turned out to be lying, it is possible that the cult can convert anybody, including Zeno.

Yes, and I am totally more useful to them than you are, Ash. [/sarcasm]

To be fair, you have played well so far.

Apparently I then found a knife on my desk and a note warning me not to push the investigation too far, because I may not like the results.

I wonder what this means.

3 to lynch.

Okay. So there are 6 of us left, and I've compiled everyone's claims below:

Zeno - Marie Schrader
ninjapenguin - Ted Beneke
Blatant - Hank Schrader
Ashrzr - Skyler White
Mozzy - Skinny Pete
Warriormario - Jane Margolis

And I bolded the three most suspicious claims. I'm not honestly sure of the best course of action, but I guess we should look at the posting history of these three and decide which of these is most suspicious. Of course, if the cult can convert anyone regardless of their role then all of this logic goes out the window.

Also since it is now only 3 votes to lynch, the risk of a cult speed-lynch is probably fairly high. As such, I'd like to ask everyone to hold off on voting at all until we reach a consensus.

Holding off from voting may mean that the inactivity clock ticks down further, making it even more likely for there to be a cult speed lynch.

It's a difficult situation, because if we vote, then a speed lynch could happen, if we don't, it could get worse.

As for the "most suspicious claims", is this based upon the show's relation to characters that have been scum previously?

Also Blatant did you get any other information about the knife on your desk or is that all you know?

Holding off from voting may mean that the inactivity clock ticks down further, making it even more likely for there to be a cult speed lynch.

It's a difficult situation, because if we vote, then a speed lynch could happen, if we don't, it could get worse.

The "inactivity clock" ticks down for inactivity, not lack of votes. If there is an active discussion then there won't be a problem regardless of votes not being cast.

As for the "most suspicious claims", is this based upon the show's relation to characters that have been scum previously?

I based it more on prevalence in the story. Hank, Marie, and Skyler are all main characters. Ted, Skinny Pete, and Jane are not. Now, we obviously know that minor characters are included in the game, but compared to these major characters they are more suspicious. Skinny Pete is especially suspicious, due to his working with Jesse Pinkman on occasion.

Also Blatant did you get any other information about the knife on your desk or is that all you know?

That's all I got in the email (though paraphrased of course).

Fair enough, although I'm pretty sure Yeeb ticked the inactivity clock down yesterday during a point of "relative activity". I don't know exactly though.

Also, who do you plan to investigate tonight Blatant?

That really depends on how the day goes. If we screw up today we may not even have another night.

That's fair, at this rate inactivity is just going to win though :/

Well, we have almost nothing to go on other than "Zeno is suspicious because he was against lynching scum," which really isn't going to get us anywhere.

My guess is that Mozzy is faking his claim because looking at Skinny Pete's bio on the wiki, I could literally count the number of sentences on there with the fingers on my hands. All the other characters at least had paragraphs. However, Mozzy could be hiding his identity as an investigative role although if he is, we would really need some help at this point where we'd lose if we lynched the wrong person.

Not heard from Mozzy in a while either. Mozzy?

Hmn I doubt that mozzy is scum because he did vote to lynch scragins which resulted in 2 cult member deaths.
So, I think that the cult isn't that big anymore because of that. Something that ninjapenguin981 tried to prevent a little bit after the accusation of blatant by voting for Herr which would have resulted in 1 cult member death. That's why I think he's scum.
Vote: ninjapenguin981