GeneralVon said I could do this one. All the replay reviewers aren't active
____________________________________________________________ ____________

Sorry GeneralVon scratmaster said he would do it

[This message has been edited by Legolaim (edited 10-30-2006 @ 01:05 PM).]

Ok, whos gonna do it? Raven, Scrat or Legolaim? I dont care really.

I'll do it.

Review is coming!

GoS[GeneralVon] (Mordor) vs GoS[iSaLdaT] (Isengard)
Played on Fords of Isen II

Player: GoS[GeneralVon]

BO: SH(x2), Orcpit(x2), Orcpit

Positives

[+]Attacking from all directions
[+]Good use of PPs
[+]Good harrasment
[+]Clumping
[+]Good spamming
[+]Good economy
[+]Got 3 nazgul + MoS midgame/lategame
[+]Use almost whole map!

[=]Medicore Micro

Negatives

[-]No early Nazgul
[-]No early Lair creeping
[-]Got fotress upgrades - IMO using the money to expand would have been better
[-]No expanding into Fellbeast/trolls/catapults
[-]^^ If you did that, it would have been all over quite a lot quicker
[-]Poor stance use overall

Player Summary

Grats on the win! You certainly deserved it. You played well over all and yor spamming worked. You pressurized your opponent into defending all the time, an advantage for you. Towards the end of the game, instead of getting Mordor's for powerful units, such as ATs, you continued spamming orcs, meaning it took longer to win. Also, you didn't use stances that well and you hardly used them at all. The next match you play I want to see those stances being used more frequently. Apart from those few things, you played very well. I can see that you are a good player and I hope to see more games from you .

Rating: 3.5

Player: GoS[iSaLdaT]

BO: Furnace(x2), furnace, Uruk pit

Positives

[+]Good economy
[+]Early Lair creeping
[+]Early Lurtz
[+]Good use of PPs
[+]Good warg micro
[+]Good use of Lurtz

Negatives

[-]Builders totally exposed
[-]No stances used
[-]No counter attack
[-]Zerg rush plan failed miserably
[-]Towards the end you focused on getting zerks when you had no units to defend
[-]Turtling never wins you games

Player Summary

You defended well most of the game. Although defending is all part of the game, attacking is the key part of the game - something which you did not do. You never counter attacked at all that game. You could have done some serious damage to your opponent, but you chose not to attack, and so you defended all game. Please look at your negatives to improve and become a better player. Some good play from you at times.

Player Rating: 2

Match Rating: 2.5

Quite an enjoyable game. Yeah, deserves the download.

[This message has been edited by Scrat Master (edited 11-02-2006 @ 03:08 AM).]

I was just showing that using just a basic unit as "orcs" could win the game with mordor if you have enof. I usually go into seige (catas and rams) mid game to finish it. If I creeped I wouldn't have been able to rush hard, Plus orcs cant kill wargs. You dont need early nazguls to win the game.

Orcs dont make much difference when using stances unless theirs a buff involved. Also, I was just showing that orc spam works though out the whole game as long as you keep the pressure on and use your powers to buff them and even getting out a drummer to make them tougher. .

In my opinion I dont think noobs should give player summaries. Hopefully kester will do something about this because im tired of you nubs giving me BS.

Not expanding into anything is not a negative. People play different, not the way you want them too.

[This message has been edited by GeneralVon (edited 11-07-2006 @ 10:53 AM).]