Welcome
• Downloads Home
• Best Files
• Review Guidelines
• Main site
• Forums
• Code of Conduct
Search

• Advanced Search
1v1 Replays
• Home
• New Releases
• New Reviews
• New Comments
• Top-Rated

Submit File
Browse Categories
New Files

1v1 Replays » dwarves versus elves rise of the witch king

Download File Post Review Post Comment

dwarves versus elves rise of the witch king
Author File Description
INSANEsameri
Posted on 02/04/07 @ 05:13 PM
File Details
Player 1's Name: insanesameri (me)
Player 1's Faction: Dwarves
Player 2's Faction: Elves
Victor: me insanesameri
this is a kool replay in which is killed the elves after the took down my fort. Its one you will want to downlaod if you play as dwarves.
AuthorComments & Reviews   ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only )
Smeagolfan24
Official Reviewer
Posted on 02/08/07 @ 06:39 PM
Rating
3.0
1 v. 1 on Celduin River
insanesameri (Dwarves) vs. Asav (Elves)

insanesameri (Dwarves)

Build Order: Mine >>> Mine >>> Archery Range >>> Mine

Pros

[+] Nice steady stream of throwers at start.
[+] Got as close to a troll lair as possible.
[+] Good use of nearby tower
[+] Once you got Gloin, the tide was turned. Slightly.
[+] Nice job using the late-game units such as the Zealots and the catapults. They were what beat the enemy waves.
[+] Kept the northern signal fire the whole game

Averages

[=] Stances! Defensive stance when not attacking!
[=] Wagon upgrades?
[=] Bought Heal when really not needed. Rallying Call would have helped way more, earlier.
[=] Didn’t really keep your outposts, but you maintained an inn a while that gave you all of your Dale archers.
[+] So-so use of Summon Dale Archers power.

Cons

[-] Bad placement of first mines and buildings. If attempting an axe-thrower rush, one should be more forward and the other protected, IMO.
[-]Early on, you almost lost one of your builders to a cave troll!
[-] Powers? You didn’t even buy any until mid-game!
[-] You let your units sit around and get killed. Better micro.
[-] Lost your fortress after waiting til the last minute to counter his Ents.

Player Rating: 3 You did some good things, but you won because your opponent didn’t get Ents. Work on your micro to seal the game quicker and easier.

Asav (Elves)

Build Order: Tree >>> Arwen >>> [Outposts] >>> Stables >>> Tree

Pros

[+] Early Arwen to capture buildings.
[+] Kept steady waves coming at your opponent, mainly of cavalry that decimated him.
[+] Nice choices with powers.
[+] Very fine defense with towers and statues.

Averages

[=] Swiftly got Mirkwoods w/ Silverthorn, but they died rather quickly.
[=] Late game heroes came rather…late, don’t you think?
[=] Legolas > Elrond in this game, at least.

Cons

[-] Normally focused on taking out units, rather than buildings.
[-] Stances, stances, stances! Your Summoned Ents could have destroyed his fortress much more promptly had they been in Aggressive Stance.
[-] Late game siege? Ents would have turned the game in your favor.

Player Rating: 3.5 I really think you played better throughout the entire match; you just got too confident and fell apart at the end. Try to improve late game strats.


Overall Score of Game: 3

Not a bad game, overall. It's a games with a lot of "waves" that was enjoyable to watch. Worth your time, if you've got the time.

Post Review Post Comment

HGDL v0.8.2
Login
Forum Username:


Password:




• Create a new account
• Forgot password?
Rating
3.0
Statistics
Downloads:267
Favorites: [Who?]0
Size:79.41 KB
Added:02/04/07
 

WARNING: DO NOT HOTLINK TO FILES
Copyright © 2006-2009 HeavenGames LLC. The graphical images and content enclosed with this document are viewable for private use only. All other rights-including, but not limited to, distribution, duplication, and publish by any means - are retained by HeavenGames LLC. Federal law provides criminal and civil penalties for those found to be in violation. In addition, please read our Disclaimer & Privacy Statement.

LOTR: Battle for Middle Earth 2® is a game by EA Games.

Battle for Middle Earth 2 Heaven best viewed with a HTML 4.0 / CSS 2.0 compatible browser.