I'm not so certain. We are playing a forum-based mafia, correct? When did Scapegoat become a term commonly used on the interwebz to describe someone at a forum? Then again, I don't know if Psycho would be something I'd immediately pick up on as a forum-based role anyway...
Now here's the interesting bit. Maegereg described the attributes in his role, likely because his role email didn't come out and say exactly what he was, whereas TBK first stated what he was, then describing the attributes of his role.
Now, in a game where the roles are a bit more obscure than others, I would not expect a role name to come before a role description. Furthermore, assuming that you guys don't have simple role names in your emails, I find it strange that TBK immediately recognized what his role was (evidenced by the order in which he roleclaimed), although bodyguard does tend to be a less common role. Conversely, Maegereg described a role that matches decently well with one of the variants of priest. Another interesting anecdote is that it is my belief that FoO made many of these roles with the idea of giving the player a hard time in mind. This is evidenced in Maeg's vote restriction, can probably be found in Normandy's role, and is supported by my role as well. However, TBK's doesn't seem to have any sort of restrictions. The only down side is that he dies if he makes a successful protection. But that is not nearly as restrictive as voting restrictions, persay.
However, for now, I won't be voting. If you guys want, we can pursue TBK, or we can move on to someone else. Personally, I think we should make a decision soon before we out someone important.
"Also, I'm no clearer on what WIFOM is really, although I gather it's something to do with Thymole being gay..." -Sassenach
"I don't lie in my claims and I don't intend to." -WeeMicky
"OH MY GOD A DINOSAUR" -Peter Fallon