Chapter Eighteen: Recriminations & Cover Ups.
“You mean to say the Peloponnesians have escaped?” Erasinides spluttered in belief.
“Aye,” Conon nodded. “They left yesterday evening and are probably headed south towards Chios,” Conon looked at the eight Athenian commanders that stood before him, as they convened inside a wrecked building in Mytilene after the city was relieved by the victorious Athenian fleet. The joy of the admirals at winning the battle and saving Conon’s battered squadron was tarnished. Their mood had soured when Conon had told them the remnants of the mauled enemy squadron had escaped. Pericles called for a guard who soon arrived.
“Find Theramenes and Thrasybulus,” he ordered the soldier. “Tell them to meet us here at once!” The guard nodded and dashed out of the building so to carry out the orders given to him. Aristocrates looked at Conon with some sympathy, as the general saw how rugged the admiral was after being blockaded and starved of food for weeks.
“Go and rest, Conon,” suggested Aristocrates. “You and your men must been tired after your ordeal. Great trials and tribulations have been hurled towards you and it has been met with sturdy defiance while facing adversity. On behalf of all the generals here we are proud of you,” Conon could see the faces of the eight generals were looks of appreciation. The Athenian showed his gratitude by nodding in acknowledgment and gratitude before heading out of the wrecked building so to find a house and bed to sleep on. When Conon left the room the generals prepared themselves, as they awaited Theramenes and Thrasybulus knowing there would be few pleasantries.
Their predictions would prove correct.
*****
“You failed to rescue any warships?” Protomachus tore into the two trierarchs after the eight generals received their report of their aborted mission to save the dead and wounded sailors that lied adrift in the Aegean.
“The weather seriously handicapped our efforts to save those men,” Theramenes protested strongly. “The rescue squadron sailed straight into the storm where most of the stricken triremes were unfortunately located,”
“Visibility was poor and we were barely able to sight any sailors that were alive or triremes,” Thrasybulus added. “As the night wore on the storm got worse that damaged some of our own triremes. We had no choice but to pull out,”
“So you just left them to their fate at the hands of a storm?” Lysias angrily shot back. “You decided to save your own backs using a storm as a excuse so to hide your deficiencies as commanders?” The two trierarchs resisted the urge to strike their generals who gave them looks of scorn and disdain. Both trierarchs were surprised that their long time friend Thrasyllus was not even being impartial towards them.
“I doubt many of you know what it is like to sail into a full bloodied Aegean storm,” Theramenes spoke coldly. “It is as chaotic as a battle and twice as deadly because you do not know when the next wave will smash your hull and tear your warships to bits. The decision to withdraw was done with much regret. But every sailor within the rescue squadron did not challenge the order. They knew if we stayed any longer inside the storm then you would have lost forty-forty five warships,”
“But thanks to your incompetence we failed to save up to a thousand men. It is likely they are all dead!” Erasinides scathingly retorted. “To make things worse the Peloponnesians have managed to link up with the fleet that besieged Conon at Mytilene. They now have eighty to ninety warships, which is likely residing at Chios and replenishing their losses suffered at Arginusae. The enemy manages to slip away in rough waters yet you balk at the sight of rough waves?”
“Then it is you who failed to destroy the enemy fleet and not us!” Thrasybulus shot back. “Moreover, from the tone of your voices it sounds like you think rescuing those shipwrecked sailors was an easy task. If that is what you think then why didn’t you lead the rescue squadron yourself?” Tempers began to rise with the possibility of blows being struck. Pericles soon stepped in before blood was split.
“Theramenes and Thrasybulus, I think you should return back to your quarters,” the young admiral suggested. “Both of us have said things that in time will be regretted. Now go to your quarters before something counter productive happens,” The two trierarchs agreed that Pericles’ proposal was wise, as both captains left the wrecked house commandeered as a makeshift command post and headed back to their quarters. When they were out of sight the eight generals looked at each other anxiously.
“So what now?” wondered Diomedon. “We head to Chios?”
“That is the likeliest option,” Aristogenes replied before shaking his head ruefully. “But the Peloponnesians are not going to come out of their harbour for battle. Their fleet is battered after the beating they took at Arginusae and have no appetite for another fight. They rather hide behind their defences knowing they can replenish their depleted ranks with Persian money. Even though we know the Peloponnesians won’t fight there is no option but to go to Chios so to keep up morale among our men,”
“That brings us to the matter of our report to the assembly regarding the battle and its aftermath,” Pericles added. This brought about looks of trepidation among the generals. They knew what happened if the Pnyx found out they had neglected to pick up the bodies themselves, as well as tasking two trierarchs to do it, while they headed towards Mytilene so to seek glory and try to destroy the enemy fleet.
“Well, what should we write in the report regarding our attempts in picking up the dead and stranded sailors after the battle?” asked Aristocrates. Silence filled the house as anxious expressions were etched upon the generals’ faces. Erasinides took it upon himself to break the impasse.
“It is clear what we must write in our report to the assembly,” he decreed. “We shall explain the truth and present the full facts of what happened. Explaining why we decided to head towards Mytilene - so to destroy the remaining Peloponnesian fleet instead of picking up the dead and dying - will help us exonerate us of all charges should we be truthful. Besides, if the Pnyx do try to cast blame then it will likely be directed towards Thrasybulus and Theramenes. But we should tell both of them our plans because if we stick to a pre-arranged story then no charges will be brought against us,” Some agreed with the plan while others did not: especially Thrasyllus.
“No, I don’t like the plan. It looks like we are trying to push the blame to Theramenes and Thrasybulus,” he disagreed strongly. “If accusations are brought against them it could put all of us in a dangerous position,”
“Thrasyllus is right,” nodded Diomedon. “Should they be charged due to us blaming them for what has happened then we could find ourselves outflanked. Thrasybulus and Theramenes are popular figures within Athens because of their efforts in the Hellespont and Aegean during the last five years. They are skilled speakers and have strong political support meaning they will be formidable foes should we turn against them. Therefore, I feel Aristocrates’ proposal is valid yet not the right choice,”
“Then what should we put in the report?” Protomachus wondered with great anxiety.
“We tell the truth,” Lysias answered back. “But we omit the true reasons behind the rescue mission and explain it was us who organised and led the mission. No blame will be cast upon one another and we will fault the storm in our failure to deal with the survivors and pick up the dead for burial. It is likely we could suffer a backlash from Athens but they will soon realize how dangerous a vicious storm can be to a fleet operating at night. However, I do agree on informing Thrasybulus and Theramenes the plan. If we form a united front then the Pnyx cannot charge us,”
“Better to suffer a backlash due to a storm that will pass over in a few days,” said Aristogenes. “But if the citizenry find out it was two trierarchs that tried to save our stricken comrades and not us then questions will be asked by the Pnyx,”
“Which is why we omit the truth and say it was us who tried to save our comrades but failed to do so because of a storm,” Erasinides added. “A storm can be seen as a legitimate reason to call off a rescue even though some storms pass quickly,” The eight generals agreed to the plan and sent their fabricated report to the assembly. A few days later the Athenian fleet sailed towards Chios so to confront the Peloponnesians. But Eteonicus was no fool and stayed within the harbour.
The Athenian armada were resigned to set sail for Samos so to rest and recuperate. A sense of frustration rippled among the generals, as their victory at Arginusae was not exploited. The generals knew that because of their failure to take advantage of their victory the Peloponnesians had a formidable fleet lurking in the Aegean eager to cut off Athens’ grain routes in the Hellespont. The only positive outlook the generals could be pleased with was the fractious aftermath of the battle had been sorted out. But what the Athenian generals did not know was there would be further repercussions out of Arginusae’s aftermath.
*****
It was mid-August as Theramenes and Thrasybulus entered Athens on horseback with one of their subordinate officers. The two ex-generals were pleased to be back home, as they scanned the city to see what had changed. Their eyes pried to the increase in soldiers upon the battlements, lookout posts and sentry towers that cluttered Athens.
“Why the increase in soldiers?” asked Thrasybulus. “What has changed in the past few years while we have been fighting in the Aegean and Hellespont?” Theramenes’ subordinate officer Antiphixus soon answered Theramenes’ question.
“A lot has happened during the last five years since the revolutions that paralysed Athens,” the officer said. Some of these events I know you are aware of but what you don’t know is the impact it has had on the city,”
“Impacted on the city how?” enquired an intrigued Theramenes, as the three Athenians used their horses to navigate the market road, which was streaming with people at this time.
“Well, the fall and secession of Euboea from the empire rattled many Athenians here,” Antiphixus explained. “The only thing separating Euboea from Attica is the Straits of Oropus and many Athenians are worried about an enemy attack. But the main reason is Agis,"
“I'm not surprised. I heard of his multiple attacks against the Long Walls of Athens not long ago,” deduced Thrasybulus. “Thankfully, the garrison commanders were able to repulse them while the bulk of the Athenian fleet was away,”
“Because of the multiple Peloponnesian assaults the city decided to step up military patrols and double the guard,” Antiphixus added. “Athens may now be awash with soldiers but at least the city is safe,” Thrasybulus and Theramenes nodded in agreement at Antiphixus’ opinion. The three men did not talk for the rest of the journey, as they headed towards the main barracks to meet an old friend who held high rank after serving under the two ex-generals in the Hellespont. The captain was certainly pleased to see them when he saw them enter the barracks.
“Thrasybulus and Theramenes, aren’t you a sight for sore eyes!” he exulted as he walked so to embrace them warmly. “How long has it been since I last served with you in battle? Four years?”
“Nearly six," chuckled Thrasybulus. “And it looks like you have made a name for yourself since then. Captain of the guard!”
“A title that I am proud of,” Philtres proudly chuckled. “But enough with the pleasantries! Accompany me to my quarters and we shall talk more!” Philtres led his friends to his quarters as the captain politely shook Antiphixus’ hand when the two ex-generals introduced him to Philtres. While making their way through the barracks the group saw new recruits training to become hoplites. Thrasybulus looked on as he saw the young soldiers be taught by an instructor who sported several scars.
“New lambs for the slaughter,” he thought darkly to himself. After a few minutes they reached Philtres’ quarters. For an hour Antiphixus heard the captain talk of tales about Thrasybulus and Theramenes in battle. Antiphixus was intrigued by the stories and with each tale brought new founded respect for his superior officers.
“So what truly brings you here to my quarters?” enquired Philtres. Theramenes and Thrasybulus looked at each other momentarily.
“We wanted to visit Athens after spending many years fighting the Peloponnesians,” Theramenes replied. “But mainly because we wanted to visit you seeing you now outrank everyone in the room!” The two ex-generals felt guilty at not disclosing the truth but that was because their trip to Athens was important. They were eager to know whether their commanders’ report regarding the battle- of which they had been told by the generals what the report entailed - contained information that could incriminate the two trierarchs and lead to charges brought against them. They had come with Antiphixus to defend themselves if necessary and decided to visit Philtres because he was captain of the guard and knew the word of the street.
“Ah, well I can actually tell you a few stories about what is happening in Athens,” Philtres replied. “Including a few interesting things regarding what happened when the people heard about the glorious victory at Arginusae,”
“How did they react” asked Antiphixus who like Theramenes and Thrasybulus were eager to hear what Philtres had to say.
“Well, when we first heard of what happened at Arginusae there was great joy and relief among many Athenians. We revelled at how our navy tore through the vast Peloponnesian fleet,” Philtres remembered with great pride in his voice as he spoke. “There was a sense of relief because the people knew if the battle had been lost then our vital grain routes would be cut off by the enemy. Then Athens would have no choice but to surrender to those wretched Spartans and their allies.
Thankfully, our makeshift fleet had the gods on their side and won the battle. An amazing feat seeing many within the armada were sons of nobles, farmers, hoplites and slaves. Moreover, the assembly in celebration passed a motion in the assembly praising the generals who orchestrated the victory,” Antiphixus, Theramenes and Thrasybulus felt aggrieved at the assembly for not praising the rank and file sailors along with the marines and rowers who died during the battle.
“But now there is a sense of growing anger among the people,” added Philtres.
“Why is that?” Theramenes said curiously.
“Not long after hearing what happened at Arginusae the people partied in the streets into the night and gave thanks to the gods inside the temples for the victory against the enemy,” Philtres replied quietly so that he was not overheard by any passing soldier that walked past his quarters. “But this changed a few days later. This was about a week ago. The mood among the citizenry changed slightly after the generals sent their report to the assembly regarding what happened at Arginusae.
“What did it say?” Thrasybulus asked as his heart began to beat rapidly.
“They wrote about how they had won the battle but also told of its aftermath,” the captain of the guard recollected. “It was sad to learn how the generals failed to save those poor sailors that lay out to sea because of a violent storm,”
“How did the assembly react?” Antiphixus asked.
“A few nobles in the Pnyx were angry at the failure to retrieve our stricken men,” Philtres replied. “As you well know burying the dead is as important as trying to save a man’s life. During this long war us Athenians, as well as the Peloponnesians, have always allowed retrieval of the dead so they can be buried. The only reason why no charges have been brought against the generals is the assembly accepted their reasons behind the failure, which was a storm. Many councillors and nobles in the assembly have served in the navy and know what it is like to sail through a punishing storm,”
“So was that the end of the matter?” Theramenes asked Philtres, as the Athenian hoped the assembly decided to focus on winning the war rather than trying to unearth more information about the failed rescue attempt.
“There is still some anger especially among those relatives of soldiers who died in the stormy waters of the Aegean because of the failed rescue operation,” Philtres said with sorrow in his voice for he felt sorry for the bereaved relatives. “But I think the clamour will die down seeing that Arginusae was a glorious victory that has helped reinforce Athenian naval supremacy,”
Theramenes, Thrasybulus and Antiphixus were relieved at finding out no action had been taken against the Athenian generals, as a result of neglecting the dead and wounded. The atmosphere within the room soon lightened as the topic turned to one of reminiscing where many laughs were shared as they looked back at good memories when Philtres served in the Hellespont. As evening arrived the three Athenian officers said their goodbyes to Philtres with Theramenes and Thrasybulus warmly embracing their close friend.
As they left the barracks the three men headed to a local inn so to stay for the night before they were to head back to their respective homes the following morning. Once they paid for their lodging the three Athenian officers could relax in their beds. They were glad that so far their pre-arranged story, which was concocted by the eight Athenian generals, was holding up and the assembly decided that no one would face charges.
Or so they thought.
General Rawlinson- This is most unsatisfactory. Where are the Sherwood Foresters? Where are the East Lancashires on the right?
Brigadier-General Oxley- They are lying out in No Man's Land, sir. And most of them will never stand again.
Two high ranking British generals discussing the fortunes of two regiments after the disastrous attack at Aubers Ridge on the 9th May 1915.[This message has been edited by Legion Of Hell (edited 05-21-2011 @ 04:58 PM).]