You must be logged in to post messages.
Please login or register

Archimedes Workshop (Tech Help)
Moderated by Chonaman

Hop to:    
loginhomeregisterhelprules
Bottom
Topic Subject: Protecting your PC from Starforce Problems
posted 06-05-06 11:18 AM EDT (US)   
I've visited the StarForce support forum, and there is no question that some users of StarForce-protected games have reported problems with optical drives. Most of the time, the support moderator has disputed the idea that StarForce is causing the problems, with responses like the following:

Quote:

99.9% this problem is not related to StarForce. This is a pure coincidence. You should try contacting your local optical drives service center.

Whether StarForce has caused these alleged problems is impossible to verify one way or the other, but many of the allegations do appear credible based on the considerable troubleshooting the users have reported. What is not obvious is what percentage of users experience problems with StarForce, especially since most purchasers of StarForce-protected games are unaware it has been installed on their system in the first place. However, it is obvious that we have few options but to try to live with StarForce now that we know it will be bundled with R&F.

My suggestions for living with StarForce are to minimize its impact on the rest of your system by setting it up accordingly. What follows is a plan to do just that (because I am definitely going to play R&F).

A) Add a new partition to your system and install a fresh version of your OS. This is relatively easy to do using Norton Partition Magic. Add all service packs and security patches to bring the OS up to current levels. Update all drivers, especially sound and video drivers. Then install R&F to that OS only, thus maintaining a completely sanitized environment where StarForce cannot impact other important apps and games that otherwise run perfectly well.

B) By doing this, users can accomplish 2 very important things:

1) Your system will be optimally configured to run this very hardware-intensive game since you will only have the OS and R&F installed (no unnecessary processes will run at startup or in the background)

2) Should you suddenly encounter problems with your optical drives on the StarForce partition, you can verify that they still work fine on your other OS, thus "proving" that StarForce is the problem, not something else. Isolating StarForce on its own partition, with its own OS is the only way to ensure that StarForce support will eventually own up to the problems/conflicts it appears to cause. On the other hand, it may also prove that StarForce runs perfectly in a sanitary environment, and simply has conflicts with certain types of software.

C) Other recommendations:

1) Do not install (any) programs, especially email programs on the StarForce drive; in fact, remove Outlook Express as well as any unnecessary apps that Windows installs by default. Depending on whether you use IM during gaming, I'd recommend uninstalling Windows Messenger if you don't need it.

2) Do not browse the web or use webmail while on the StarForce drive.

3) Do not install any Anti-virus software (you won't need it if you aren't using email, chat or a web browser)

4) Do not install any 3rd party software firewall. Use Windows XP firewall if you have a direct (cable modem or dial-up) internet connection; if you're using a router, disable the XP firewall unless the router's built-in firewall is not enabled or the port blocking rules have been significantly modified for other uses)

5) Definitely do not install any software on the StarForce drive that is used for copying CDs or DVDs. These have been known to cause problems with games in general, not just those protected by StarForce.

Sure, this will take some time, but I think the benefits outweigh the potential problems StarForce may cause, and games on the dedicated gaming OS will run much better.


Total War Heaven Former Angel Cherub and Long-Time Contributor

[This message has been edited by Chonaman (edited 06-05-2006 @ 11:25 AM).]

Replies:
posted 06-05-06 11:43 AM EDT (US)     1 / 18  

Quote:

but I think the benefits outweigh the potential problems StarForce may cause

I really don't see how...

Also, I understood that Starforce can also physically harm your Hard disk, is it true?

posted 06-05-06 12:13 PM EDT (US)     2 / 18  
Fantastic post. I've never made a partition before, so I'll probably only try this as a last resort if things don't work otherwise, but it's great to see solutions to these possible problems before the game is even released.

Wok?
posted 06-05-06 12:51 PM EDT (US)     3 / 18  

Quote:

Also, I understood that Starforce can also physically harm your Hard disk, is it true?

I haven't seen any posts (that are credible) showing that StarForce physically damages hard disks, although I have seen some (possibly credible) that suggest it may harm optical drives. Most of the problems appear to be software conflict related, with occasional corruption of files. This isn't unlike many other types of software that may be incompatible with existing products on the system.

The likelihood is (IMO) very low that StarForce would physically damage hardware since it is a software product that installs low-level drivers, and these drivers are (intended only) to enable or disable your ability to run the game based on the checks it does. Of course, because it is a very low level driver, if it is badly written, it could potentially cause what seem to be hardware problems, but some of these have been resolved simply by reinstalling the OS, with no permanent damage to hardware.

The reason I'm suggesting people install the game on a completely separate OS is to avoid major problems should they occur on their primary OS/partition. With a dual-boot system, once you reboot to the original (standard use) OS you have no problems because the StarForce drivers will not run.

Here's a very informative post from UBISoft from last October. It details the types and percentages of problems they documented from games that have used StarForce. One thing to keep in mind is what I've already pointed out; a lot of users never knew StarForce was installed on their systems, so they probably didn't know who to complain to about problems that occurred.

Making a new partition is very easy using Partition Magic, and installing a new OS isn't hard or time consuming. Probably the most time-consuming part of such a project is adding the service packs and patches. I recommend making a slipstreamed version of Windows XP if possible, which makes the process faster, expecially if you rebuild your PC more than every year or two.

You can also create a custom, modified version of Windows XP to install by using nLite, also a very useful thing to do.


Total War Heaven Former Angel Cherub and Long-Time Contributor
posted 06-05-06 09:06 PM EDT (US)     4 / 18  
Anyone knows if the game is compatible with Windows Vista Beta 2 (5384)? I'm planning to install it this summer, and I'd like to run it on Vista
posted 06-05-06 09:19 PM EDT (US)     5 / 18  

Quote:

Anyone knows if the game is compatible with Windows Vista Beta 2 (5384)?

This is really OT for this thread and this thread is pretty important, actually.

However, to your point:

New Windows OS's are generally quite compatible with recent software products and games, so I'd guess there would be no problem. However, that' really a question for Microsoft, since they are releasing their OS after R&F is released. You can't promise to make current software (R&F) compatible with something that hasn't been released yet (Vista). Unless of course, you're a Microsoft developer.


Total War Heaven Former Angel Cherub and Long-Time Contributor
posted 06-07-06 08:42 AM EDT (US)     6 / 18  
If Windows vista will have compatability modes, it could run as good as it does on windows xp (with compatability mode set on windows XP)

[This message has been edited by The_lucky_man (edited 06-08-2006 @ 12:45 PM).]

posted 06-07-06 08:51 AM EDT (US)     7 / 18  
The only problem with the new version of Starforce is that your CD/DVD drive could be damaged if you burn CDs/DVDs while you have Starforce installed. Just don't do any burning and you will be 100% safe.
posted 06-07-06 08:55 PM EDT (US)     8 / 18  
hmm i have a question will starforce be on every single raf game?
sumtimes sum ppl would be lucky enough to not get it at all u never know
posted 06-08-06 12:58 PM EDT (US)     9 / 18  
StarForce is part of the code compiled with the game. There is only one version of the game at this time, and that's probably all there ever will be until/unless Midway offers an add-on to the game.

Total War Heaven Former Angel Cherub and Long-Time Contributor
posted 06-08-06 02:09 PM EDT (US)     10 / 18  
Can a partition be added to the hard drive without reintalling everything else on it? And explain what opticals drives are. CD/DVD burners?

.....................................
...............(\ /)................
..............(^.^)...............
.............<( < )...............
...............(/ (/................
...All American Bunny.....

[This message has been edited by _o0XxX0o_ (edited 06-08-2006 @ 02:30 PM).]

posted 06-08-06 03:39 PM EDT (US)     11 / 18  

Quote:

Can a partition be added to the hard drive without reintalling everything else on it?

The beauty of Partition Magic is that you can completely reorganize a hard disk at any time without having to rebuild your system from the ground up. Take your existing system, which may have a single 60 GB partition and make it into two logical 30 GB drives, for instance. The primary limitation is how much free space you have on the physical drive, as you don't want to have PM move data around while it's repartitioning.

You can create a new partition and install a new OS in about 45-60 minutes if you know what you're doing.

Quote:

And explain what opticals drives are. CD/DVD burners?

Optical drives are CD and DVD drives, which use optics (lasers) to read and write data, unlike Hard drives/disks which use "heads" to transfer data.


Total War Heaven Former Angel Cherub and Long-Time Contributor
posted 06-08-06 03:52 PM EDT (US)     12 / 18  
I just talked to a computer specialist. He said just go ahead and install the game with the StarForce. If there is a problem, then just use the uninstaller, or find a crack for it, or even use the partition program.

He also said that if there is a program already installed on your computer that is like Deamon, one that copies an image of the game to your hard drive for the purpose of emulating the disc, that StarForce will get pissed at it, and will do bad things.

*added later*

After looking around, it looks like bypassing earlier versions of StarForce copy protection is easy. But later versions are more suited to handle Daemon tools. That is exactly why there have been a lot more problems with later versions(as mentioned to me by the computer specialist).

StarForce is an extremely intrusive program. I don't want to pirate their game, I just want to protect my optical drives from it. There is a program called StarForce Nightmare that hides your cd/dvd drivers from their program. By itself that would not be enough to come even close to playing the game without the CD(or dvd). But it would possibly prevent StarForce from affecting the optical drivers will the game is not running. Or at least the ealier versions. The later versions may be a problem.


.....................................
...............(\ /)................
..............(^.^)...............
.............<( < )...............
...............(/ (/................
...All American Bunny.....

[This message has been edited by _o0XxX0o_ (edited 06-08-2006 @ 04:09 PM).]

posted 06-08-06 04:20 PM EDT (US)     13 / 18  

Quote:

I just talked to a computer specialist. He said just go ahead and install the game with the StarForce. If there is a problem, then just use the uninstaller, or find a crack for it, or even use the partition program.

It's important to remember that StarForce does not harm most computers it is installed on, and that no one here should get hysterical about the fact that it's bundled with R&F, unless they have a bunch of pirated software on their system, or cracking tools, or imaging tools which StarForce may not like. Users who have the highest risk certainly know who they are, and frankly they also should know how to partition a drive and reinstall a second OS to avoid problems with StarForce. If not, this would be a good time to learn.

If you're running a second OS, StarForce will have zero effect on your optical drives on the first OS. That's why I am running the game that way. That's not to say that I fall under the category mentioned above; I don't have any pirated software or anything that StarForce would take issue with. And so far, no problems at all, btw. I do have to protect my system though, since I run my business from it on one partition/OS.


Total War Heaven Former Angel Cherub and Long-Time Contributor
posted 06-08-06 04:50 PM EDT (US)     14 / 18  
Read this article.

http://www.cdfreaks.com/news/13212

SCARRY!!! I don't want some piece of CR*P program like this on my computer!

Besides partitioning the HD costs MONEY!!!!

Going out and spending $20-$60 for a partition program and installing OS is way, way too much trouble.

Besides, as it stands I don't know how to do all those things and I'm sure a lot of casual computer people don't either.

All this for 1 game? BOYCOTT, BOYCOTT, BOYCOTT!!!!


.....................................
...............(\ /)................
..............(^.^)...............
.............<( < )...............
...............(/ (/................
...All American Bunny.....

[This message has been edited by _o0XxX0o_ (edited 06-08-2006 @ 04:59 PM).]

posted 06-08-06 05:19 PM EDT (US)     15 / 18  
That post has largely been discredited, and according to the "update" link in the article you referred to, FutureMark has denied it had anything to do with "investigating" StarForce software.

The support forum at StarForce has several threads like the one you mention. To their credit, the mods there allow such postings and they respond to them regularly (although as I've noted, the repsonses have not always been what we would call "professional" or "courteous"). I chalk a lot of that up to the fact that these guys are Russian programmers, probably former hackers, and not PR guys by any means.

There are a lot of accusations about StarForce, and while a few are credible, I do not believe this product is going to be a problem for the vast majority of R&F players. I am always cautious personally because of what I use my PC for, and because I actually find it interesting to have a system that is built the way it is. It was fun setting it up. Your mileage may vary.


Total War Heaven Former Angel Cherub and Long-Time Contributor
posted 06-08-06 07:35 PM EDT (US)     16 / 18  
Fear was definately talking. The big companies seem to have so much power, with nothing anyone can do about it.

Also it seems there is a lot of talk about how very few cracks are availible for StarForce games.

I just wish they would make a seperate version with no copy protection for people like me. People who actually buy the game, and never give it away for free, or for any amount of money.


.....................................
...............(\ /)................
..............(^.^)...............
.............<( < )...............
...............(/ (/................
...All American Bunny.....

[This message has been edited by _o0XxX0o_ (edited 06-08-2006 @ 07:36 PM).]

posted 06-12-06 08:50 AM EDT (US)     17 / 18  
i have a new dvd today...

i don't take risks, no starforce in my system.

not buying the game, so frustrating.

posted 06-12-06 10:37 AM EDT (US)     18 / 18  

Quote:

i don't take risks

LoL, every time you install a hotfix for Windows you're taking a risk. Every time you install a new piece of software you take a risk. Every time you open an email attachment you're taking a risk. Every time you browse an unknown web site you take a risk. The list goes on and on.

We all choose our risks based on the rewards we want. I'm willing to take the risk of installing StarForce because the reward is to play Rise and Fall, and it has been a blast playing the full version of the game! Too bad some people are too intimidated by internet heresay to give it a try.


Total War Heaven Former Angel Cherub and Long-Time Contributor
Rise and Fall Heaven » Forums » Archimedes Workshop (Tech Help) » Protecting your PC from Starforce Problems
Top
You must be logged in to post messages.
Please login or register
Hop to:    
Rise and Fall Heaven | HeavenGames