I have received one action. Come on, people!

...

Actually, you have three hours to send in your night action if you have not sent it in. I do not prod; I do not randomize.

[This message has been edited by Mozzarella Man (edited 09-22-2010 @ 03:58 PM).]

It is now Day-1.

The mothers of MAD have apparently had quite enough of Dr. Red Apple. It was second breakfast time when Dr. Apple's neighbor, Mr. Any Citrus Ever, went to check on him. Mr. Ever found Dr. Apple dead, and I'm tired of writing this terrible flavor, so I'll just tell you that Catabre (the doctor) has died.

There are six of you alive, so it takes four votes to lynch. Choose wisely.

...

If one of you two up top can replace Heir, that'd be much appreciated.

...

Apparently not.

[This message has been edited by Mozzarella Man (edited 09-22-2010 @ 07:06 PM).]

I'll play, don't worry.

Well, there's one person who'll play.

Ok, so you need a mass prod.

Gil should be active from tomorrow onwards.

I'm surprised I wasn't killed. (Premature and silly) deductions:
Gil is not scum.
Dom is not scum.
I am not scum.

Guessing from the people who would probably consider Cat a big enough threat to kill him first, I would have to say that Brighty tops my list of suspects.

Heir is the most interesting character right now.

He evidently didn't send it a night action, leading Mozzy to think he needed to be replaced. However, we still had a kill.

He wasn't the doc, leading me to think he's our cop. The other option is that he's the mafia killer, and Mozzy went to another mafia member to get his action.

I don't think we have anyone on the game besides mafia/doc/cop; probably a 2v5 situation.

IF we have another cop who investigated someone besides Cata or Heir I'd like us to discussion the pros and cons of having them reveal... I think we'd catch scum (Heir) and potentially clear two players (cop + their target). We'd lose our cop, of course, but with the small number of players finding one scum is worth the cop

I asked to be replaced because of events in another game, but thought the better of it.

@Mozzy - You need to change the title of the thread, each time I look at it passing it reads like "CUM Game Thread" which is just plain wrong.

at it in passing

Fixed.

I don't prod. Players can feel free to prod for me, but I don't prod as a rule.

Well, if I had a mod here....

Just call it Completely Unannounced Mafia. Who needs the vanilla anyway?

Confirmed.
Who am I replacing?

I'm here!!


@Heir-How did you come up with those conclusions? [Just the last two, I'm fine with the first one ]

Good luck town!

im fine with the first too, personally i think heir will be innocent! but Brighty seems like the most experienced member left who would think that catabre is a threat to mafia so

Vote: Brighty

Because if either of Gil or Razor were scum they would have killed me first. I'm not sure about Razor, but I think that's how Gil would operate.

if i was mafia,i wouldnt have aimed for anyone in particular due to my newbieness :P

anyway what are other peoples views on catabre's death?

Ensemble (Nax) has replaced Brighty.

I think Heir is suspicious because Catabre was not so well known as Heir, who is known to be a good player. Since people would aim for the veteran players first it seems most likely that someone would go for heir, unless Heir is part of the mafia.

Or mafia know that I'm smart and since I'm well known I am likely to be protected. Again, I deem you, Gil and Razor to not be experienced enough to think as deeply as that, and since I know I'm not scum, that leaves Brighty and Ferret.

The "deep thinking" thing above is not a slight on any of you, just speaking from what I used to do earlier on. You guys might well be much more mentally developed than me. I know Gil is.[/hilarious joke]

I kept checking the sign up thread and just assumed Mozzy was really lazy. CUVM is very ambiguous.... And now I'm replaced.

Sorry about that. I responded to you via MSN.

I know Gil is.

Face it, I'm awesome. We had this discussion earlier also.

But your logic is correct. However, normally,I'd have targeted you with my ability, not killed you. Would have been too obvious.

Now where?

Only if it's not an exam Gil, only then.

Now that we know that Brighty was inactive, because if he had an action and had sent it in, then he wouldn't have been replaced, it only stands to reason that Ferret is our most logical suspect, unless he has logic to the contrary. Therefore, I demand that either Ferret produce that logic in court or reveal his true purposes in this game.

Okay, with 6 players, there should be 4+2 system.
According to Heir analysis,
I'm not scum.
Dom is not.
Heir isn't since he didn't send in his action very early.
Brighty/Ensemble isn't since he was inactive.

Not sure about Davstar.

All right, we go with ferret. And its a while since he posted.

There were originally 7 players Gil, so it would be 5+2. But I don't think there are 2 scum. I never said there were.

If we had 2 scum, then town would start in a lynch or lose situation (working the math). We're dealing with only one scum on here.

Gil, ftr, Heir's analysis is complete bull and really has no rational backing to stand on. It's all well and good to try and guess who would do what but the majority of Heir's argument assumes that you, Davstar & Razor aren't independent enough to pick a random name out of a list, and would instead target someone they know.

That's bull.

UNVOTE

VOTE: Ferret

for the fact he is trying to divert suspicion away from himself onto Heir when heir is innocent.

And i doubt there is more than 1 scum.

Well, Gil and Razor at least have already confirmed my assumption to be true, so...

This game is so wtf

This game is so wtf

Eh?

lol

Vote:Ferret

This is a pretty small game. Its not supposed to stretch out late. The town suspects you.

Hmmmmm Ferret's words are logical and it is natural to try and defend yourself from people trying to lynch you.

Also i've not yet seen any proof that heir is innocent R4zOr94 unless your a cop and have a report on him all we have is heir's word that he isn't in the mafia. If you do have proof is innocent I will concede the point and join you on voting for Ferret but at the moment I find Heir too suspicious.

for the fact he is trying to divert suspicion away from himself onto Heir when heir is innocent.

How do you know Heir is innocent?

Ferret: 2 (Dom, Gil)

It looks... pretty cut and dry for me. Vote: TheFerret.
Even if we screw this up, we have another shot tomorrow. Unless Mozzy was a complete moron made an uncharacteristic error and put the town straight into a lynch or lose situation with six players.

Alright I'll hammer.
vote:Ferret

I feel your pain ferret. Even if you're scum, that was, well... strange...

Strange? not really. That was old school mafia, no rhyme, reason, common sense or logic behind it!

I'm a VT, by the way. Nice job guys.

Mr. Vanilla I. Cream has been lynched. He was a vanilla townie, and an enemy of Mothers Against Deliciousness (MAD).

It is now Night-2, send in your actions.

WTF? You lynched him without him even claiming? Seriously?! I mean, can't a guy even sleep in peace? How idiotic!

Seriously?!

2 votes were enough for pressure.
That was real scummy Davstar, first defending Ferret and then hammering him!

Seems like we didn't realize our mistakes from Religion Mafia.

Both mine and ferrets words fell onto deaf ears, my voice wouldn't have swayed you from your course so i saw no need to try. Besides I have had my reservations and I still find it suspicious that Heir, who started as a suspicious character, being easily claimed as innocent, and the person being suspected being hounded even when he defended himself with logic. I also find it suspicious that both gil and r4zor just follow Heir's opinions. I've not yet seen any evidence to say heir is innocent and he started the hounding of a townie, why am I the only one who finds that suspicious? I hammered him to continue the game and I was right in trying to defend a townie.

Both mine and ferrets words fell onto deaf ears, my voice wouldn't have swayed you from your course so i saw no need to try.

And what would you define as our course? Lynching Ferret? Did I say even once that I wanted him lynched?

You claim that you defended a townie despite having hammered him? And then you blame me of all the people when I was the only one who didn't vote for Ferret? Are you serious?

Come on Davstar, if you're indulging in a blatantly scummy action, at least make your reasons less stupid.

WHOA! WAIT! WTF! Ferret wasnt meant to get lynched only pressured o.O