I like where this is going.

I love the flavor.

Can we please have a player list? I have no idea who's in the bloody game.

Vote: If_I_Was_Ville

I know for a fact you're playing.

Vote Ash

He's obviously Scum. Sorry Ash but I saw right thou it.

Vote: TCM

Who's TCM?

Well I don't think names will mean much, but we have character descriptions (and we know who would be in a bank). I think we should just go to the next day and see what happens in the night. Vote: No-Lynch

Vote: Scargins No Lynch without even discussing is a bad idea.

We can go around random voting and getting one or two claims, risk revealing power role.

Or no lynch.

I'm fine with anything.

Vote: Herr

It's so obvious he's scum, just look at the way he's acting.

Why would a random vote reveal power roles?

I suggest people claim only their role-names as in the flavour, if pressurised.

I like the idea of Scargins claiming because of the No lynch Vote.

Claim Sir.

Well it is for exactly this reason I wanted a no-lynch.

I am Anthony, the security guard and I feel bad for letting the mafia into the bank with weapons (neglect of duty). I am a 1-shot Vig and if I kill a town player I die.

Doc protection tonight please.

I dont see why you need protection if you die if you kill a townie as it would help mafia if two townies die because of you so they wont kill you. Also you seem to get that role a lot scragins

Well I am a 1-shot Vig and currently the only claimed power role. The role I really want is a Serial Killer not a vig thats 2/4 out of my last games I've been 1 shot vig.

Uhh, Daimond, the mafia have reason to fear from him if he targets a mafioso tonight.

I suggest the Doc protect Scar tonight, and we have no more power role claims today.

Daimond's play is really ridiculous here. Last post to be precise.

Well I don't think I'm going to target anyone tonight.

Abhaas, Watson that was a joke. Didnt you notice the ' ' in it?

Well, in the past Mole have used one of the points against me to be that i have a 50% chance role and when i was mafia i claimed as a 1-shot doc in Mafia of the sponge.

I think Mozzy is a Jester for voting himself.

He's obviously Scum. Sorry Ash but I saw right thou it.

Yep, I'm the SK.

Ash can't possibly be the SK, I'm the SK!

Not again

*twiddles thumbs*

Unvote, Vote: Thymole

That's the second time he's been useless Day 1 in a mafia game. The first time, he was most assuredly scum. I've noticed that when Mole is town, he plays really aggressively, but as scum, stays out of the spotlight. For those of you who aren't fond of metagaming, I still assert that as a standalone contention.

I don't like day starts

and everything posted thus far has been worthless

Also I'm town in the other game so the point is null.

I'm town guys

Why don't you like Day Starts?

Night Starts:

1) 95% of the time ensure at least one person won't even get the chance to play.
2) Force players to use their actions when they have no discussion to go on.

Day Starts:

1) Give lots of behavior analysis.
2) Get players into the mindset of playing mafia based on fundamentals and not relying on unreliable night action results.
3) Give all players a chance to play.

I don't understand why anyone would possibly dislike Day Starts. In any case, my vote stays. When you're passive and not active, you always show up on my scumdar, Mole. It's out of style for you.

Also I'm town in the other game so the point is null.

More Kara Logic™. You were incredibly scummy in that game, and no one but you knows if you're scum or not, so the point is not null in this game.

IWAV and Mozzy: fooling around, nothing to say

Daimond and Scragins: Playing normal. I hate how people think no lynches on D1 are scummy. Fact is, a good number of people think D1 is a waste. Usually it is. But more often than not its those who accuse the person of wanting a no lynch that are scum, if either of the two are at all. Still, nothing to say here.

Gil: Has been extra fearful of any claims at all for the past few games. Don't know why but he's being normal.

Spook: Can't tell if he's joking. Not sure

---

Iwav

What do you think about ash's post that was against me

Think it's truthful that ash thinks I am scum in Pulse's game?

IWAV and Mozzy: fooling around, nothing to say

That's how they always play.

Fact is, a good number of people think D1 is a waste.

No they don't. Only noobs do because they don't know how to properly play the game. Day Starts have been held in high regard by veteran mafia players for years.

Usually it is.

If we followed your directive they would be a waste.

I hate how people think no lynches on D1 are scummy.

If you would've been asking a question, you pretty much would've answered it. If the first thing you do on a Day Start is advocate a No Lynch, you've wasted it. And wasting anything in mafia is always scummy.

What do you think about ash's post that was against me

What the hell? You smiled.

Gil: Has been extra fearful of any claims at all for the past few games. Don't know why but he's being normal.

Aye, claims can be bad. Claims should be asked only for substantial reasons.

And yeah, I'm not too happy with day start, unless someone spice it up with SK counterclaim.

Step #1 to dealing with Day Starts: stop worrying about the fact that it's a Day Start and play the game.

Welp, we have one claim so I don't think our Vig should fire and hopefully we have a doctor.

Also I will claim because I have an iron role and I have an idea how to use my role to a cop type effect.
So after this claim I suggest we cease claims and just go into night after everyone has had a say on what they think yes?

I am One Shot Iron Mason recruiter. So I cannot be killed together assuming that no host in his right mind would put two night kills in a Mafia this size. But I die if I try to recruit scum. So Tonight I will attempt to recruit Thymole, That way if I am alive you know Thymole is Town. I suggest whatever cop role we have investigate someone else. I believe Scargins claim because its as weird as mine. I think Ash would be a good investigation.

Also if you have a survivor role I think You should wait to claim on Day 2 so we can have a better idea of what we're up against based on NK's yes?

Tis a good idea I believe.

Josh, I don't understand your role. If you die, you recruit scum. But like you said, it's 99% likely you won't die tonight. Yet you say you're recruiting Thymole tonight. I'm slightly confused.

He dies if he tries to recruit Scum.
He doesn't die if scum try to kill him.

Oh, and why Thymole?

Y U NO THINK ABOUT ME VILLIE?

Oh, I read that wrong, I thought it said if I die.

Why Thymole? Why ME? What have I done to warrant investigation? Thymole's the one suggesting a no lynch and wasting the day.

I just wanted to clear to people that seemed to be at one another already. That way, no one gets tunnel vision on each other and we have 3 to 5 confirmed town on Day 2, whats not to like?

Where are you pulling the fact that Mole is the cop from!?

And IWAV's plan seems reasonable.

I don't think anyone said Mole is the Cop.

I wanted to confirm Mole because Ash and Mole are already at it with one another. *Scroll up*

I figured I would confirm Mole and the Cop could confirm Ash.
Then we know we have a Cop, myself, and then our two investigaties, Plus our one shot Vig.

That's Five reasonable townies by Day 2 or we've already caught scum, one of the two. Win-Win for town yes?

The problem is, he could be lying. A one-shot iron mason recruiter doesn't really fit in an 8-man game at all. Plus, I think we all remember his recent shennanigans.

Then again, this is a Lordy game.

Then we know we have a Cop, myself, and then our two investigaties, Plus our one shot Vig.

I see several problems.

1) What if I or Mole are the cop?
2) What's this about a Vig?
3) What if you're lying?

I don't like the plan. The Day hasn't even lasted 24 hours yet, anyway.

*Cough* Ash...Uhh.

List of players:
1-ThyMole(thymole@yahoo.com)
2-The Unconvincing Spook(Holmeswatson86@yahoo.com)
3-Ashrzr(ashrzr@gmail.com)
4-IfWasAVille(AoE3boards@gmail.com)
5-Henry(Henrz.Me@Hotmail.com)
6-Daimond Daimondo(daimonddaimondo@yahoo.in)
7-Gil(hg.periagil@hotmail.com)
8-Herr(ritvikmats@gmail.com)
9-scragins(basebilbo@gmail.com)
10-Mozzarella Man(pspaperstacks@gmail.com)


10 Man game and its a Lordy. So picking apart roles is going to be kinda tough. Considering we dont even have an idea of NKs yet.

Oh, 10 people, that makes much of a difference.

Too many holes in the plan, mate.

1) What if I or Mole are the cop?
Then as I said 3 to 5 out of 10, thats still pretty good, plus we're expecting at least one death tonight. We still come out pretty excellent.

If Ash is the Cop then, You can investigate someone and give us your result. I will recruit another person Night 2 and even if I'm dead that person should still be able to talk to Thymole and he would confirm them.

If Mole is the Cop then, We will know hes town and we can work out investigations away from the eye of the scum between Mason Comm.

2) What's this about a Vig?
Scargins claimed as a One Shot Vig that dies if he hits town, I think we can trust him on Day 1 since I made him claim, and let him have the Cop protection so we can Vig when we have a lead.

3) What if you're lying?
Then Mole can confirm he wasnt recruited and I cannot talk to him and I'm lynched. Pretty silly way to die.

I belive Villies role as my role is a very low used and strange too.

1) What if I or Mole are the cop?
Then as I said 3 to 5 out of 10, thats still pretty good, plus we're expecting at least one death tonight. We still come out pretty excellent.

Problem is, how are you in any way, shape, or form confirmed?

2) What's this about a Vig?
Scargins claimed as a One Shot Vig that dies if he hits town, I think we can trust him on Day 1 since I made him claim, and let him have the Cop protection so we can Vig when we have a lead.

When did he claim that? I missed it?

3) What if you're lying?
Then Mole can confirm he wasnt recruited and I cannot talk to him and I'm lynched. Pretty silly way to die.

You could be a Cult Leader. You do realize you sound a lot like one, right? It's a 10-man game so the chances of there being a Cult Leader is slim, but still, I don't like or trust your plan.

He claimes post 12. And villi I think you mean doc protection not cop protection