Alright, on Day 1, we discussed mechanics for a while. There was a push for a no lynch, but we stopped it at least until we finished organizing foraging. We organized the town into Group 1 (players 1 through 8 in the OP) and Group 2 (players 9 through 16 in the OP). Group 1 forages on odd nights and eats/ and uses actions on even nights. Group 2 forages on even nights and eats and uses actions on odd nights. Then Coldviper, out of the blue, showed up and ended day, casting the final no lynch vote. Not only that, but he went foraging in the most dangerous zone even though it was made clear that he should be using his action that night.
No one died on Night 1. This meant that our killer or killers were likely in Group 1 (or Coldviper), since they were likely foraging on Night 1. We got 5 supplies, as I recall. THYMOLE and Coldviper both got sick. On Day 2, we pressued Coldviper for spontaneously ending day and foraging when he shouldn't. He made a claim, and it was determined that his claim was a lie. We began the lynching process, but he intentionally edited a post and got himself modkilled. Turns out his claim was a lie. He was just too stubborn to admit that he was actually the doctor, even if it might have saved his life.
Day 2 didn't end there, though. After we finished organizing foraging, we began pressuring members of Group 1. Henrz claimed as a Miller Vigilante, and so we lynched him. He was the Serial Killer, it would seem.
Other claims include Moajor as some sort of investigator, THYMOLE as a psychiatrist (though his role is more like a miracle worker in nature), and my claim as an endowed towny (basically means I have a collection of random one-shot abilities).
Tonight, Group 2 is foraging, and Group 1 is using actions.
"Also, I'm no clearer on what WIFOM is really, although I gather it's something to do with Thymole being gay..." -Sassenach
"I don't lie in my claims and I don't intend to." -WeeMicky
"OH MY GOD A DINOSAUR" -Peter Fallon