I see what you mean isch, but I'm indifferent to lynching either xefus, isch, or the knight. I've stated my rationales before.

All right then. Let Xefus be lynched.....

CV, I think you meant pressured. Lynching someone who, IIRC, hasn't claimed isn't a good move.

I said lynched ? You know what I mean

I know this is going to sound incredibly scummy, but whatever we decide to do, let's just get it DONE.
(Note that I'm promoting decisiveness, not speedlynching)

That is completely self contradicting

But again, there isn't any point in pressuring Xefus, cause he isn't going to turn up. So, if we vote for him now, we vote with intention to lynch.

Personally, as I said earlier, I'd rather lynch someone who's already claimed, but if the town wants to go with Xefus, then so will I.

In my opinion, Isch has a perfectly reasonable claim. Heir has already explained why he wasn't able to kill him one of the nights. Isch probably kept playing because it was fun, but since some people have become inactive he slipped into inactivity too.

Vote: Xefus
Best lead we have at the moment.

I know this is going to sound incredibly scummy, but whatever we decide to do, let's just get it DONE.
(Note that I'm promoting decisiveness, not speedlynching)

That is completely self contradicting

Perhaps I didn't explain myself very well. It is a bit unclear.
Whatever we decide to do, we should do. As in, "Ok, x looks scummy. Let's give them a chance to defend themselves. Do they still look scummy? (if yes) then let's lynch them. (if no) ok, who's next on the most-likely list?

NOT:
"OK, X looks like scum. Hm... but... Maybe it's Y - NO, it's Z! But... What about A? ... Hmm... Maybe we should... Look at X? But... Y... Ahhh..."

And ALSO NOT:
"OK, X looks scummy. Bitch be going down! LYNCH!"

Personally, I think no.2 is happening now. It's all good to try and get information, but there's a difference between getting information and running around in circles.
Just my two cents. I'm not the best mafia player going around (Needless to say).

Oh, and by the way, lynching inactives is fine with me, if for no other reason is that the town doesn't actually LOSE anything.
Henceforth
VOTE: XEFUS

I would also be voting for xefus if I could. But since I can't, it's 4 more votes for xefus to be lynched.

Wait....just out right lynching a inactive? Even the black night would be better than that. Surely we have some better options?

I'm a little suspicious of Ensamble for suggesting an out right lynch of someone who we have no reason to beleive to be scum. FOS Ensamble

He's just doing what the rest of us are, I can't really blame him.

Truth is, we have no leads, and this way we're at least getting rid of the dead wood. Xefus is at best nothing, at worst a liability to the town because of 0 info. With his lynch, we might at least get some info.

GAME NOTICE: I'm out pretty much every weekend now until the 17th of July. I won't be here at all from 26/6 to 1/7 due to a Biology field trip. So I'll reduce the number of votes to lynch if we're not in night some time next week so day 6 can begin before I leave.

Quoted from Heir:

Truth is, we have no leads, and this way we're at least getting rid of the dead wood. Xefus is at best nothing, at worst a liability to the town because of 0 info. With his lynch, we might at least get some info.

Heir speaks truth. We might get some kind of info, and it means that a) an inactive liability to the town is removed, and b) that we don't run the risk of paralysing the game by voting out every active or semi-active player.

unvote, just in case

Vote: Xefus

Sounds good to me, I was starting to get bored with all the nothing going on...

Unvote: Newt_Gunray

Vote: Xefus

Two more votes to lynch...

Heir's quote sums it up perfectly.

Unvote
Vote: Xefus

We are probably going to get no where, though I suppose we have little other alternatives.

Vote: Xerfus

Vote: Newt. WRP is dead.

Yeah, I recall Newt stating he'd protect WRP.

Vote: Newt for rather obvious reasons.

I take it the Black Knight a vig kill, Henrz?

He did not get back up, for people were already upon him

More than one?

but unfortunately he had run straight into his killer.

Singular.

I reckon we've got 3 left?

Quite confusing, too- though Newt was apparently pegged to protect WRP, we have Charlie waiting for WRP. How far can we trust these writeups, Yeeb?

Vote: Newt

Indeed. Vote: Newt

Hmm. Odd that both the bodyguard and the target were killed. I guess WRP was attacked twice or something.

I guess WRP was attacked twice or something.

Yeah, it's mildly disturbing, as it means suddenly we've got a kill from nowhere that wasn't around in previous nights.

And, there we go again, back to the only source of an extra kill from the previous nights, the Witch Hunter.

I think there could be a mechanic where he had to gain points before attaining a kill power or something, considering that his arch rival the Witch had a similar system.

I think we should discuss where the extra kill could've come from. We already have our lynch target for the day, no need to rush things now.

Didn't think of that.

FoS: Ischenous

vote newt
i think we ought to kill em both...

Quite confusing, too- though Newt was apparently pegged to protect WRP, we have Charlie waiting for WRP. How far can we trust these writeups, Yeeb?

I have to write these things to make them mildly interesting and not to give everything away. For example I can't post the graphic details of how a pink unicorn brutally impaled WRP_Beater at the command of Minos Yewman. (It did not...)

So you should not attempt to infer anything from my write-ups. Just look at the kills if you have to.

Oh... It didn't?

I think we should discuss where the extra kill could've come from. We already have our lynch target for the day, no need to rush things now.

Mm, because even discounting the Black Knight as Vig Kill, that still makes us wonder how the kill broke through doctor protection.
1) A kill on the doc stops his action going through. (Unlikely)
2) A doctor's protection stops one kill action (More likely)
3) Doc was Roleblocked (Not me- I actually forgot to send my action in ) (Only if there's a mafia roleblocker running around)

So you should not attempt to infer anything from my write-ups. Just look at the kills if you have to.

Well, that's just maddeningly unhelpful

But I think the manner of the deaths have been reasonably consistent with those who have killed them. So I'm going to make a personal guess and say we've still got a 1-person faction and a 2-person faction still running around

Why are we trying to lynch newt? Did he claim doctor?

I guess I can't sign in as a replacement now, isn't it true? Also Yeeb, fix the HTML/BBCode in the main post.

I was blocked 'by a foreigner'. I'm guessing that means French, unless anyone else has any ideas?

Why are we trying to lynch newt? Did he claim doctor?

Apparently, yes. He promised to protect WRP, but... well... he's dead, so this logically means that he isn't a doctor... or something else is going on.

I can double vote today, but I want to see what's going on first.

I was blocked 'by a foreigner'. I'm guessing that means French, unless anyone else has any ideas?

Well, I can think of two things- we've got another Frenchman running around, or he's talking shit, and we're fresh out of Frenchmen.

Vote: Newt

Funny how only you have mentioned an e-mail from being role blocked.

What can I say? I don't send out the emails. I was told my action was blocked, as I say, by a foreigner. And if I wasn't a doctor, why would I say that I would protect WRP Beater knowing that he's a pretty big target on the mafia's list? That makes no sense. Just like the effort to try and lynch me without even waiting for an explanation.

What can I say? I don't send out the emails

Henrz, Baske and (presumably- I haven't heard any comment from him regarding it) Brighty certainly haven't received any.

And if I wasn't a doctor, why would I say that I would protect WRP Beater knowing that he's a pretty big target on the mafia's list?

Yeah, I don't really need to answer that, do I?

Just like the effort to try and lynch me without even waiting for an explanation.

You gave it, I call bullshit.

Quoted from EoJ:

Henrz, Baske and (presumably- I haven't heard any comment from him regarding it) Brighty certainly haven't received any.

And how do you know that? Has it been explicitly mentioned?

Quoted from EoJ:

Yeah, I don't really need to answer that, do I?

Well, yes, actually. That would be nice.

By claiming doc and saying you will portect wrp you garuntee that no one else will block him leaving him open for a kill. Also, why did you recieve an email at all?

And how do you know that? Has it been explicitly mentioned?

An e-mail like that would be mentioned. Even as "Oh, that explains the e-mail I got".

Well, yes, actually. That would be nice.

Claim as doc, offer to protect target, real doc doesn't protect, use window of opportunity to kill target, kthxbai. The loss of a mafia member is outweighed by that of a cop.

No one so far in this game has claimed to get a email.

Vote: Newt

Which means, what? Because no-one has mentioned it, doesn't mean it hasn't occurred.

Quoted from Thymole:

By claiming doc and saying you will portect wrp you garuntee that no one else will block him leaving him open for a kill.

Sorry? If you recall, I was asked to protect WRP. It was faulty planning, left me wide open to be blocked and thus him wide open to be killed.

I didn't get an email.

Here's the deal, if you're not scum we go kill EoJ, since he's a french RBer.

So there is no way we can confirm if Newt is really a doctor?

Perhaps it would actually be better to lynch frenchie and than newt. It occured to me that EoJ's claimed role is much less valuable than Newts. His story is doubtful but we could play it safe. I also have issues with trusting frenchie considering the movie ends with a failed attack on the French... Opinions?

I'm not good with hunches, but I really have no idea if the french would be mafia or just survivors (They are isolated in a single castle and tell Arthur to go away), the game seems to be following the flavor as well (3 times iron, made me lol).

I think we best go for Newt, but I'd like to know what the rest think.

Perhaps it would actually be better to lynch frenchie and than newt. It occured to me that EoJ's claimed role is much less valuable than Newts.

Oh, I disagree. Newt claimed a sort of Jock of all trades. One shot doctor, one shot cop, one shot roleblocker. He's expended every single one of those powers now, so we'd only be losing a VT. That in itself is no excuse to lynch, but I don't buy the "oh, I guess the thing that was supposed to confirm me didn't happen, so let's lynch this other person in an attempt to confirm me again" routine. If we've got to pick between the two of them, Newt is by far the lesser loss, and of the two he's coming across as way scummier.

Also, the HTML in the player list has become rather badly screwed up.